Hi drcrystalbeal ,
Is this happening on the beta version of Buttonizer or version 2.0.9?
This sounds like it might be a caching issue. Do you perhaps have a caching plugin?
If so, most caching plugins support a exclude option.
Could you try following this topic on how to exclude Buttonizer on caching plugins?
Exclude Buttonizer from W3 Total Cache
The steps should be aroud the same.
Let me know if this was the case! 😀